Mastering Outliers in Time Series: Identification, Removal, and Strategic Use Through Box Plots
How Do You Handle Outliers in Time Series Data?
Should You Remove All the Outliers?
When Should We Incorporate Outliers?
By understanding how outliers relate to the distribution of our data, and visualizing them with tools like box plots, we can make informed decisions about managing them.
Before we deep dive into details - Check out resources below
referrals → Join
Student Scholarships → Resources
Hiring updates → Job board
Now, Let’s continue and understand boxplot use case in outlier detection,
Understanding Box Plots
A box plot is a helpful tool for summarizing data distribution by visualizing a five-number summary:
Minimum: The lowest value in the dataset.
First Quartile (Q1): The 25th percentile, marking the median of the lower half.
Median (Q2): The central value, or 50th percentile.
Third Quartile (Q3): The 75th percentile, marking the median of the upper half.
Maximum: The highest value in the dataset.
Why Use a Box Plot?
Box plots make it easy to see distribution characteristics, including:
Outliers Identification: Points outside the “whiskers” (the lines extending from the box) are considered outliers, allowing you to quickly spot unusual values.
Distribution Visualization: The box length represents the Interquartile Range (IQR), showing the spread of the middle 50% of data points.
Comparison Across Categories: Multiple box plots make it easy to compare distributions across time periods or categories.
Example: Using Box Plots to Analyze Click Data for Fintech Products
Consider weekly click data over several weeks for three Fintech products—Mortgages, Student Loans, and Credit Cards.
Interpreting the Box Plot
Box Length (IQR): The length of the box represents the interquartile range (IQR), showing the data’s central spread. A narrow IQR indicates stable, predictable values, while a wider IQR suggests more variability.
Mortgages: Narrow IQR indicates consistent click patterns with minimal fluctuations.
Student Loans: Moderate IQR, suggesting some variability in clicks over time.
Credit Cards: Wider IQR and potential outliers, pointing to greater fluctuations in click numbers.
Whiskers: Lines extending from the box represent the general data range, excluding outliers.
Whiskers help capture the extent of the dataset’s main body, showing the usual range without including outliers.
Outliers: Points outside the whiskers are outliers, representing values significantly different from the rest.
Outliers can indicate events such as promotional spikes or errors. For example, Credit Cards may have high variability and occasional spikes in clicks, which may be due to specific campaigns or seasonal trends.
Should You Remove All Outliers?
Not necessarily. Here are general guidelines:
Remove Outliers If They’re Errors: If outliers result from data entry mistakes or equipment malfunctions, removing them is beneficial to avoid skewing the results.
Remove Outliers If They Don’t Reflect Normal Conditions: If you aim to model standard behavior, exclude extreme values that don’t represent usual trends (e.g., one-time traffic surges due to a special promotion).
Retain Outliers If They’re Meaningful: Outliers often carry valuable insights, such as capturing high-impact events like a successful marketing campaign or seasonal peak in demand.
When Should We Incorporate Outliers?
Outliers Reflect Natural Variability: In industries like finance, price swings and volatility are normal, and outliers can help capture these dynamics.
Analyzing High-Impact Events: Outliers can represent special events, like peak sales during holidays, essential for accurate trend analysis and future preparation.
Scenario-Based Modeling: Including outliers allows for scenario testing, helping assess model robustness under extreme conditions, which is useful for risk management.
Handling Outliers in Time Series Data
When dealing with outliers in time series data, it's essential to adopt a systematic approach to ensure that your analysis remains valid and meaningful. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to effectively handle outliers:
1. Identify Outliers
Visualization Tools: Use visualizations such as box plots or scatter plots to detect outliers in your time series data. Box plots can help you quickly spot points that lie outside the whiskers, indicating unusual values.
Statistical Methods: Implement statistical tests or algorithms, like the Z-score method or the Modified Z-score, to quantify how far each point deviates from the mean. Generally, a Z-score greater than 3 or less than -3 may be considered an outlier.
2. Investigate Outliers
Contextual Analysis: Examine the outlier's context within the time series. Look for patterns, such as seasonality or trends, that might explain the outlier. For example, a spike in clicks for a specific product could correlate with a marketing campaign.
Root Cause Analysis: Determine if the outlier is due to a data error, a natural occurrence, or an anomaly. Understanding the cause will guide your next steps in handling the outlier.
3. Decide on Action
Remove or Adjust: If the outlier is due to an error (e.g., incorrect data entry or system malfunctions), it's best to remove or correct it. However, if the outlier reflects a genuine phenomenon (e.g., a peak due to a holiday sale), consider keeping it for analysis.
Transformation: In some cases, applying transformations (like logarithmic or square root transformations) can help mitigate the impact of outliers while retaining the underlying data structure.
4. Incorporate Outliers in Models
Scenario Analysis: When building models, include outliers if they represent significant events that could impact future trends. This is particularly relevant in fields like finance, where price swings are part of the market dynamics.
Robust Modeling Techniques: Use robust statistical methods or machine learning algorithms that are less sensitive to outliers, such as decision trees or ensemble methods. This allows your models to better accommodate outlier data points without skewing the results.
5. Monitor and Update
Ongoing Evaluation: Continuously monitor your time series data to identify new outliers as they emerge. Time series data can evolve, and what might have been an outlier at one point could become a regular pattern later on.
Model Reassessment: Regularly reassess your models and analyses to ensure they remain relevant and accurate in light of new data, including outliers.
Summary
Box plots offer a straightforward way to identify and assess outliers in a time series dataset. Deciding whether to remove or incorporate outliers depends on whether they represent data errors, unusual anomalies, or significant events.
Remove outliers if they reflect data errors or distort typical conditions.
Incorporate outliers if they capture natural variability or highlight meaningful events that are valuable for scenario testing and trend analysis.
Handling outliers thoughtfully allows for a truer representation of the data, resulting in more accurate models and actionable insights.
Follow on Linkedin